The Gadgeteer

Summary

Gadget Review

Advertisement
Review at a glance

Manufacturer: XM Radio

Price: $69.95

Pros:
  • Affordable, easy set-up, intuitive interface, CD quality sound, does not require
  • Internet connection, never ending selection of music and talk/news shows.
Cons:
  • Not really a "con" but, as with any satellite
  • application, you want to have the best line of sight that you can. XM Radio
  • recommends a "South" facing window but, you may be able to receive the signal
  • through a wall or roof.  XM also uses terrestrial repeaters so you might be able
  • to receive a signal without  aiming the antenna South.  There is also a monthly
  • cost and the darn thing is addictive!!
  •  
Categories: More reviews like this one:

[discuss this review (0 comments so far)]

Advertisement
Advertisement

XM PC Satellite Radio

Gadgeteer Hands On Review by Adam Zeit and Eric Smith

June 27, 2003

Product Requirements:
Device:
PC with the following minimum requirements: Pentium®-class processor; Operating System: Microsoft® Windows® 98, Windows 98 Second Edition, Windows Millennium Edition, Windows 2000, or Windows XP; Memory: 32 MB of RAM & 15 MB of hard-disk space; CD-ROM drive for software installation; Sound card or powered speakers; Available USB port.

Wow!  Good things do come in small boxes.  Before I start this review, I must confess that I am an XM satellite radio freak.  I have one in my car, the home version via a boom box for portability, and now XM PCR.  By now, most of you have heard about satellite radio from either XM or Sirius.  Both offerings are fairly similar.  They each offer 100 stations that are broken down between music and talk/news stations.  The Sirius stations are all commercial free.  With XM, about 60% of their stations are commercial free.  The monthly fee for Sirius is $12.95, while XM will set you back just $9.99 for the first radio and $6.99 for the next four via their family plan.

Now, on to the review.  You will soon learn how easy it is to have satellite radio blasting through your PC speakers with CD quality and without any impact on your Internet connection.  Did I mention "no impact on your Internet connection"?  We're talking satellite here people.  You can now strut your stuff as you walk the dog down the sidewalk.  Beat your chest and proclaim "I am in direct contact with a satellite that is speeding along at 6,881mph and 20,300 miles above my head!!!"  Come on guys, I know I am not the only one who does stuff like that...am I??

I was amazed that everything I needed came in such a small box.  The box contains the receiver, a small satellite antenna (with about a 30' cord), USB cable, cable that plugs into your sound card or powered speakers, and a CD with the XM PCR software. 

Installation

Installation is a breeze.  Like most USB devices, you load the software first and then make the hardware connections.  The receiver is connected via a supplied USB cable.  There is a cable that goes between the receiver and the PC's sound card or a set of powered speakers.  Lastly you plug the antenna into the receiver.  No power cord needed, as power is supplied via the USB connection.  You need to have a view facing South.  My antenna is on a window sill.  It points through the window, goes through a few trees and is not pointing exactly South...and I still get a strong signal.  Reception should not be a problem unless you are facing due Northward.

Operation

This is where the fun begins.  There are seven screens that you get to use.  The main screen is the Channel Guide.  This is where you get to see all 100 channels or a subset of just Music, News/Talk, Last 10 stations, and four lists that you can customize.  The columns are adjustable and show station number, title, artist, category, channel name, and a column that shows what percent of your time is spent listening to a particular channel. Just click on the station and you are switched to the new song or show.  There is about a two second lag time.  The channel guide is shown in real time so you will see the songs change when the guide is displayed.

One of the nicer features is the "Save Info" capability.  When you see a song you like and want to save the info about it, just click on the "Save Info" button on the bottom of the screen.  XM PCR will store the date/time, artist, title, and channel info.  It is not saving the song for playback...just the info about it.  Very convenient for those that want to do MP3 harvesting.

The other screens are pretty self-explanatory.  There is the "Signal Level" screen which is very helpful in positioning your antenna.

The "Settings" screen shows the different options you can adjust.

There is one more screen that is very useful.  I call it the "Mini-Me" screen. This is a small version on the Channel Guide that will stay on top of your screen.  It shows the Channel Number, Artist, and Song.  It also gives you the ability to change stations, save the song info, mute, and expand to the full Channel Guide.

Sound Quality

The quality of what you hear is going to be based on what you are using for speakers.  I use a Monsoon speaker set-up and the sound is fantastic!  The signal is 100% digital and of CD quality.  There is no hissing, snap, crackle or pop.  Just pure music.  I cannot tell the difference between a CD being played or a song being delivered by XM PCR.  Remember, you are not using your Internet bandwidth so your connection speed has no bearing on sound quality.

Side Benefit

I quickly discovered a nice bonus when using XM PCR.  I use a program called Media Center from J.River. This is an "all-in-one" application that rips, burns, plays, records all of my music and video files.  I use it for syncing my Ipod and found it to out perform Window's Media Player.  Media Center enables you to record anything that is coming through the input port on your sound card.  Took me a New York minute to realize that the Chris Rea live concert recorded by the BBC a few years back could be recorded and converted to an MP3 file...oh my.  I can even program Media Center to start recording a specific time.  Now I can capture all of the Lone Ranger and The Shadow shows that air on the XM's Radio Classics station.

Please forgive my enthusiasm for this product.  If you love music, want a large selection, a slick interface, CD quality sound without any impact on your Internet connection, and enjoy things with a big "WOW" factor, you will not be disappointed with XM PCR.  You can find more info, view the user's guide, and get ordering info at http://www.xmradio.com/xmpcr.

XM PCR is currently available online through PC Connection.

Price: $69.95 and either $9.99 or $6.99 monthly fee

Pros: Affordable, easy set-up, intuitive interface, CD quality sound, does not require Internet connection, never ending selection of music and talk/news shows.

Cons: Not really a "con" but, as with any satellite application, you want to have the best line of sight that you can. XM Radio recommends a "South" facing window but, you may be able to receive the signal through a wall or roof.  XM also uses terrestrial repeaters so you might be able to receive a signal without  aiming the antenna South.  There is also a monthly cost and the darn thing is addictive!!
 

Advertisement
Review Summary

Manufacturer: XM Radio

Price: $69.95

More reviews like this one:
Pros:
  • Affordable, easy set-up, intuitive interface, CD quality sound, does not require
  • Internet connection, never ending selection of music and talk/news shows.
Cons:
  • Not really a "con" but, as with any satellite
  • application, you want to have the best line of sight that you can. XM Radio
  • recommends a "South" facing window but, you may be able to receive the signal
  • through a wall or roof.  XM also uses terrestrial repeaters so you might be able
  • to receive a signal without  aiming the antenna South.  There is also a monthly
  • cost and the darn thing is addictive!!
  •  
Categories:
Discussion (0 comments)
Post A Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login:
Password:

Note: Forum accounts do not work for the new comment system. You may create an account by visiting this page.

Gadgeteer Forums

Post your comments here on the XM PC Satellite Radio.

http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/xm-pc-satellite-radio-review.html

Just click the POST REPLY button on this page.

posted June 27, 2003 17:44:13 PM by Judie

I'll admit that I've been curious about XM radio for some time....but the question I haven't heard answered...is whether they work at all indoors.

Specifically, would it work from my cubicle at work.

It is the one place where I can't get radio.... I also barely get cellular....

I really don't want to buy it and then find out the answer is no....since I can't think of any other reason to justify having it otherwise.

The Dreamer

posted June 27, 2003 19:25:41 PM by TheDreamer

The answer is yes and no...sorry. I can pick up a signal from within my house but, the room I am in has no ceiling. The roof is on top pf me and the signal seems to get through. I also cannot get cellular reception so I don't think you can draw a parellel between the two. The good folks at XM are going to hedge their bets and tell you no. These are pretty power birds they have up there in outer space. I have been able to get a signal as I drive most of the way through a tunnel (short one). You get a lot of bounce effect with the signal. An office building is going to be tough, unless you are near a window. I would suspect that you have something more significant than a thin wood roof over your head. The call to XM is free. Give it a try.

Eric Smith

posted June 27, 2003 19:45:37 PM by redbike2001

I purchased Satellite radio in February and I decided to go with Sirius for $12.99 per month. While it is more costly by $3 per month, Sirius allows me to stream its music stations on any high speed Internet connection using my password. Talk stations (news, entertainment, etc. may not be played via the Internet.) It sounds as if this new XM PC device is limited by location but has better sound quality. Has anyone compared the XM device with the Sirius streaming feature?

posted June 28, 2003 10:44:43 AM by buffasnow1

I'm a huge XM fan too but I'm not a fan of this review. It has some major omissions and mistakes. Here they are:

1) You do not need a southern facing window for XM if you live in or near a major metropolitan area in the continental US. XM has over 800 terrestrial repeaters located around the country that provide a signal even if you don't have a direct view of the satellite. These allow XM to work in cities where tall buildings block the signal (e.g., NYC) and in tunnels, near mountains, etc. Since the vast majority of the country's population live near repeaters, you can likely put the antenna anywhere you want in your house.

2) Even if you don't live near a repeater, XM's 2.3 GHz satellite signal passes through wood and a variety of insulation materials, meaning it may come straight through your roof. If so, you can just point the antenna south irresepective of where a window is. (If you're in a steel or metal frame building, this won't work.)

3) The whole issue of commercials is very misleading, The Sirius stations are not all commercial free. Sirius, just like XM, rebroadcasts content from a variety of external providers, (e.g., CNN on XM), and you will hear those commercials. Sirius is commercial free on its music channels. XM is commericial free on 60% of its music channels. That being said, XM strictly limits commercials on the channels that provide them and it is nothing like the 20+ minutes/hour of commercials you get on regular AM/FM radio. You may get 1-2 minutes of commercials per hour and XM guarantees it will never go above 5 mins/hour on the 40% of channels that provide them. For what it's worth, I don't mind the 1min/hour of commercials I hear on the channels I listen to. (XM commercials tend to be somewhat irreverant.)

4) Both XM and Sirius have digital signals but they are NOT CD quality. XM's music channels have roughly 16kHz bandwidth and are heavily compressed using proprietary codecs. (Similar for Sirius.) The general consensus seems to be that some people care about this strongly but most people either don't care or can't hear the difference. You certainly won't notice the difference in your car at 60mph on the highway. Also, for what it's worth, I think XM has better audio fidelity than does Sirius, but your milage can and will vary. Finally, the codecs can also be updated by the companies on the fly as technology improves.

I'd suggest if you're interested in XM, you might check out http://www.xmfan.com, which is one of the several popular fansites created by XM users.

Fitz

posted June 28, 2003 11:00:11 AM by fitzsimmons

[ 29 more comments on this review -- join the discussion ]