The Gadgeteer

Summary

Gadget Review

Advertisement
Review at a glance
Product Requirements:
  • A digital music player

Product supplied by Headphone World

Manufacturer: Skullcandy

Price: $149.95

Pros:
  • Excellent noise reducing capability
  • Great sound
  • Collapsible for travel
  • Very comfortable
  • Long battery life
Cons:
  • LINK Technology did not work well with my phone
Categories: More reviews like this one:

[discuss this review (0 comments so far)]

Advertisement
Advertisement

Skullcandy Proletariat Noise Cancelling Headphones with LINK Technology

Gadgeteer Hands On Review by Judie Hughes

August 28, 2006

I should start this review with the statement that anybody who travels needs a set of noise reducing headphones. But the fact is that NR headphones shouldn't just be used when sitting on a plane next to a frustrated parent who is holding a squalling baby. NR headphones are a great way to cut out any obnoxious background noise, they can make things quiet enough that the wearer can sleep, relax, or even work more productively in the noisiest environment. When used in conjunction with a set of NR headphones, digital music players can put the listener inside their own personal music studio - with no external noises to mar the quality of the audio.

Today I am going to tell you about the Skullcandy Noise Cancelling Headphones with LINK Technology, which I have been using for the past month.

Specifications:
Driver units - 40mm
Frequency Response - 20Hz - 20kHz
Impedance - 32 ohms
Sensitivity - 121db/mW (when power is ON)
115dB/ mW (when power is OFF)
Noise Reduction Level - up to 18dB at 300Hz
Power Supply - 2 x AAA batteries (included)

Included in the package are the headphones, a LINK handsfree device, a dual plug adapter, 2 AAA batteries, a travel pouch, warranty information, and a user's manual.

LINK Technology simply refers to the ability of these headphones to connect both to the user's digital music player and to their mobile phone when using the included LINK cable. This add-on allows calls to be made and taken while the headphones are being worn.

According to the Skullcandy site, "The market for these headphones is anyone who wants to enjoy their music without having to hear the noises that are present around them all the while being able to answer cellphone calls hands free. The Proletariat NC is like having your own personal phone booth. The headphones are the only noise cancellation headphones that use Skullcandy's award winning LINK system, making it possible for the user to listen to music without outside noises and take phone calls into their headphones, all hands free."

The LINK JACKED system consists of a "Super-Sensitive" microphone built into an approximately 2" long x 1" wide plastic clip-on remote control. The device has a black plastic button which can accomplish several different functions including "connect, disconnect, last-call redial, voice dialing, mute, etc.," depending upon "the specific functions of your particular cellphone." On my phone, pressing and holding the black button brings up the "Say A Command" prompt through the voice dial function. Pressing the button again ends the call.

The wheel controls the volume of the music, and the attached cables are long enough to allow the phone and music player to be tucked in separate pockets.

My mobile phone is a Samsung A900 and while it is not specifically listed in the list of compatible mobile phones, everything fit and worked correctly. However, while calls made through the headset sounded absolutely fabulous on my end - as if I were in an isolation booth, it was so clear - persons on the other end complained of crackling and allover poor sound quality, as if I were talking from inside a barrel. Here is an example of me talking, see what you think:

Sample while sitting at my desk

There seemed to be no point in recording a sample while driving - I don't think it could have possibly sounded any worse. Therefore I would have to say that in my testing the LINK performed poorly. That's not to say that it wouldn't work better with a different phone...but I don't think it should make that big of a difference. It's a good thing I wanted these for their noise reducing properties while listening to music, because that is the area in which the Proletariats excel.

These headphones are sized to completely cover the wearer's ears, with earcups measuring 3.75" tall x 3" wide. These earcups are generously padded in soft material that feels like leather, and they are easily the most padded and most comfortable earphones I have worn in years - taking me back to the days when I wore my father's huge hand-me-down Sony headset.

The left earcup has a sliding battery compartment...

...that when opened reveals a slot for the two included AAA batteries. I am still on my original pair of batteries, which seems pretty good considering that these are not a brand that I recognize and I have used this headset for hours on end. At the base of the left earcup is the jack for either the regular headphone jack cable or the LINK handsfree device cable.

The volume adjuster controls the volume of the music through the headset - whether or not the power is turned on.

With no music playing, when the headset is turned Off, there is a sound dampening effect that is immediately evident simply because the headset is covering the wearer's ears. Music coming through the headset while it is turned off sounds fine, but perhaps a little bit muddy and dull; which can be compensated for by adjusting the digital music player's equalizer settings.

Switching the slider to the On position activates the headset's noise reducing properties, and there is a immediate feeling of sound pressurization and quiet. It is as if the cone of silence has been lowered...

But if music is playing - whoa. The music is clearer, louder, and the sound is incredibly good. The headphones sit securely on the wearer's head, and through the many possible adjustments a very comfortable fit is quickly possible. I can sit for hours with these on my ears; there is no crushing pain like I have received from smaller headsets, and there is no fear of accidentally knocking loose the speaker - which is a common sensation for me when wearing earbuds.

Considering that such a big set of headphones is being made and marketed for travelers, they should be collapsible - and these are. The Proletariats fold in the center of their leather-touch padded headband, and the joint above the earcups also folds inward. The earcups can then be further turned inward at a 90º angle (not shown in this picture) to allow them to easily tuck inside the travel pouch - a bundle measuring approximately 5.5" tall x 4" wide x 4" deep. They are obviously more bulky than a slender set of earbuds would be, but their noise reducing properties and comfortable fit make the extra space a worthwhile trade-off, at least for me.

If you have been looking for a noise reducing headset that is compact, delivers great sound and is reasonably priced, then these definitely fit the bill. Unless your phone is listed specifically as compatible with the LINK device, you might want to save the extra $20 and get the unLINKed version. I have a trip to Thailand coming up in September, and I fully intend to spoil myself with the isolation provided by the Proletariats; no crying babies, chatty seat mates, or engine noise for me...maybe I'll even be able to sleep! :0)

Skullcandy Noise Cancelling Headphones with LINK Technology are available from Headphone World and other retailers.

Advertisement
Review Summary
Product Requirements:
  • A digital music player

Product supplied by Headphone World

Manufacturer: Skullcandy

Price: $149.95

More reviews like this one:
Pros:
  • Excellent noise reducing capability
  • Great sound
  • Collapsible for travel
  • Very comfortable
  • Long battery life
Cons:
  • LINK Technology did not work well with my phone
Categories:
Discussion (0 comments)
Post A Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Login:
Password:

Note: Forum accounts do not work for the new comment system. You may create an account by visiting this page.

Gadgeteer Forums

Post your comments here on the Skullcandy Proletariat Noise Cancelling Headphones with LINK Technology.

http://www.the-gadgeteer.com/review/skullcandy_proletariat_noise_cancelling_headphones_with_link_technology

Just click the POST REPLY button on this page.

posted August 29, 2006 16:09:37 PM by Judie

Judie, or others,

Can you compare the Skullcandy Proletariat (SC-NCL $149 list but $109 at Amazon, SC-NC $99 list but $75 at Amazon) to the leading competitors: Sony MDR-NC50 ($199 list but $125 at Amazon), Bose QCII ($299 list), or the Plane Quiet Solitude ($199 list)?

posted August 30, 2006 11:56:37 AM by jiraffe

Ha! Based on price alone I would go with the SC-NCs! ;)

I don't have the other headphones to compare, so hopefully others can write in with their experiences. :0)

posted August 30, 2006 14:10:41 PM by Judie

hi Judie,

Just to give you some update. The Skull Candy looks exactly like the Creative HN-700. Right down to the jack, Volume control, On/Off and Power LED. The main difference is that the Creative HN-700 does not comes with the LINK Technololgy cable.

Given that the HN-700 cost about half the Skull Candy, it is hard to justify it as a good buy.

A link to the Creative HN-700 for comparison:
http://www.creative.com/products/product.asp?category=437&subcategory=439&product=11392

posted September 02, 2006 09:58:06 AM by sigh

<<< I have a trip to Thailand coming up in September, and I fully intend to spoil myself with the isolation provided by the Proletariats; no crying babies, chatty seat mates, or engine noise for me...maybe I'll even be able to sleep! >>>

A very unsatisfying and (dare I say) inaccurate review, Judie. Unless Skullcandy has managed a huge breakthrough in NR technology, there is NO active NR system (including Bose, which remains the gold standard, though at a hideously expensive price) that will silence crying babies, chatty seat mates, etc. It's unfortunate that you would lead your readers to believe otherwise. Active NR cancels noise in a fairly specific frequency range--hence, they're very effective at silencing engine noise and other background sounds at a similar frequency. It does little for crying babies and the sound of speech, in general. I know because I recently returned a set of the latest Bose headphones, after expecting them to provide the kind of noise isolation that I get from Etymotic. It's not even close. With Bose NR engaged, I still was perfectly able to have a conversation with the flight attendant.

I'm sure that the pads which surround the ears on the Skullcandy 'phones are providing some passive reduction of external noise (which you also get from the Bose), but anyone expecting the "silence" you're suggesting will be seriously disappointed, especially if that crying baby happens to be in the seat behind you. The best in current noise reduction (and the only type which provide something approaching true silence) is the passive isolation provided by in-the-ear-canal 'phones from Etymotic, Shure, Ultimate Ears, etc.

This is not to say that the Skullcandy 'phones (or others employing active NR) are "bad" at what they do--they're not--you just need to approach them with the right expectations.

posted September 05, 2006 09:40:50 AM by Charlesn

[ 5 more comments on this review -- join the discussion ]